Correction policy: how we handle errors in published reports

Started by DevReview · · 28 replies · 3,066 views

corrections

This happened to me last month and I still don’t totally know what to make of it.

I’ve changed my mind on this twice in the last year so take my current position lightly.

This is the sort of thing that never gets written down anywhere so I figured I’d ask.

Interested in actual experiences, and please say when you’re guessing.

28 comments 3,066 views Jump to comments

28 comments showing 4

30

Mass spec gives you molecular weight, which confirms identity but says nothing about whether the sequence is correct. Two different peptides can share a mass.

Share
8

Source though?

Share
22

Any update on this?

Share
86

The methodology page covers the weighting question directly. Purity gets the largest share because it is the most reliably measurable thing they assess.

Share
6

ngl i had the exact opposite experience but ok

Share

Join the discussion

Create a free account to reply, follow this topic and get notifications.

Create account Sign in