Reading SURMOUNT-5 critically: endpoints, dropouts, and what the 95% CIs hide

Started by MetaAnalyst Verified · · 46 replies · 3,890 views

Member since Oct 8, 2025 · 141 posts

A methods-focused walkthrough of the head-to-head trial, because effect-size headlines are doing a lot of unearned work in this comparison.

Replies — showing 2 of 46

92 posts

The treatment-regimen-estimand vs. efficacy-estimand distinction is the single most misreported aspect. Both numbers are real; they answer different questions.

35 found helpful

342 posts

Also worth flagging the open-label design — hard to avoid with distinct devices, but it matters for patient-reported secondaries.

22 found helpful

Join the discussion

Create a free account to reply, follow this topic and get notifications.

Create account Sign in